hot from the oven

FRESH SLICES

Hand-stretched dough, house-made sauce, and fresh toppings prepped daily.

Canandaigua, NY Palmyra, NY
Combo Deals

More pie,
less dough.

Three ways to feed the family and friends for less. Mix it your way — every combo's built for sharing.

Best value 01 2 Slices
& a beverage
$12
02 12" Sub, chips
& a drink
$16
Game day 03 Lg cheese pizza,
36 wings & 2L soda
$50
Specialty Pizza

The pies worth
the wait.

TheGrandma

House marinara, mozzarella, roasted garlic and torn basil. Square, crispy-bottomed, the way Sunday should taste.

MarinaraRoasted garlicBasil

TheMag Pie

Butter-garlic sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, roasted garlic and spinach. A white pie that doesn't whisper.

WhiteRicottaSpinach

ThePestroni

Basil pesto, mozzarella, cup-and-char pepperoni, finished with a drizzle of hot honey. Sweet, salty, a little dangerous.

PestoCup & charHot honey
12" Small+$2 / topping$13
20" Large+$3 / topping$24
16" Siciliansquare · +$3 / topping$18
Build your own Cup & Char PepperoniSausageMeatballCrispy / Grilled ChickenBaconTraditional PepperoniBlack OlivesJalapeñosMushroomsRed OnionRicottaRoasted Red PeppersBroccoliSpinach
By the Slice

Grab & go.

Cheese or Pepperoni
hot & fresh, all day
$5
Specialty Slice
grandma · mag pie · pestroni
$6
Calzone
mozzarella · +$2 per topping
$13
Chicken Wings

12 ct · $12

Golden-fried and tossed in your choice of sauce:

Werewolf-Style Wings

A sweet-and-spicy sauce built on Calabrian chili, then finished on the grill. Order under a full moon.

The Whole Menu

Everything else
we make by hand.

Find Us

Two shops.
One family.

Canandaigua
395 S. Main Street, Canandaigua, NY 14424
585·396·2840
Mon – Thu11am – 8pm
Fri – Sat11am – 10pm
Sunday12pm – 7pm
Palmyra
505 W. Main Street, Palmyra, NY 14522
315·502·0108
MondayClosed
Tues – Thur11am – 9pm
Fri & Sat11am – 10pm
SundayClosed